Post / EN /

Series Summary — Why Gold Inflation Is Hard, and What Can Still Be Done

The full arc from money circulation to durability-based sinks, resource turn-ins, dynamic rebalancing, and the concrete numbers that make the proposals workable.

The desire to keep gold inflation under control in World of Warcraft: Forever is reasonable. Under the current design it is also structurally difficult. Gold is printed by ordinary play (quests, loot, vendor trash). The largest sinks (class training and riding) are paid once per character and then stop. Ongoing sinks (repairs, Auction House cuts) are real but modest relative to continuous generation. There is no Token and no other external faucet, yet the internal faucets never turn off.

This series maps that circulation and then proposes three interlocking changes that increase the number of places where generated gold or the resources that produce it can be removed.

The Circulation Problem

Raw gold enters through quests, mob and chest loot, and vendor sales of trash. Once created it moves between players via trades, Auction House sales, and tips. Only the Auction House cut (5% on faction houses, 15% on the neutral houses) and direct payments to vendors or trainers destroy it. Player-to-player transfers do not reduce the total supply. Over time the supply therefore rises whenever faucets outpace sinks. That is the basic loop.

The Proposed Changes

  1. Durability destruction with multi-path Rebinding.
    Gear reaches a hard limit and is destroyed. Restoring it (“Rebinding”) can be done with a craftable consumable (sold on the AH or used by the owner), a player trade service, or an expensive vendor / rare-currency / PvP-faction purchase. Demand scales with play and death rate instead of stopping after the first few repair cycles.

  2. Permanent repeatable resource turn-ins.
    These grant Rebinding (or the materials for it) in exchange for the same cloth, ore, herbs, or leather that would otherwise be vendored for gold or listed on the Auction House. Resources are removed upstream of gold generation.

  3. Dynamic rebalancing algorithm.
    On a weekly (or limited daily) cadence the system adjusts vendor prices, turn-in quantities, and, where needed, drop or spawn rates. It can vary parameters by market so that players who treat the Auction House as their game are encouraged to move goods along A → N → H → N → A. The existing 15% neutral cut becomes the friction cost of that flow.

The Numbers That Make It Concrete

Documented Auction House rules supply the baseline:

  • Faction cut 5%, neutral cut 15%.
  • Deposits (after the minimum drops to 1 copper): 5% / 20% / 60% of vendor sell value for 2 / 8 / 24 hours.
  • A full equal-price A → N → H cycle destroys ~19.25% to cuts alone.

Recommended starting parameters:

  • Single-use Rebinding Kit vendor price: 50–100 g (worked example: 75 g when the craftable version sits at an 8 g AH median).
  • Resource turn-ins: 1.2–1.5× the post-cut AH value of the materials (worked examples: 26 Mageweave-style cloth, 27 Thorium-style ore).
  • Algorithm movement cap: ±25% per reset.
  • Cross-market differential: 10–20% difference in turn-in demand is enough to push volume through the neutral house.

These figures keep the vendor path a clear premium, the turn-ins competitive but not market-killing, and the algorithm predictable. They also rely on the fee structure that already exists rather than inventing new percentage taxes.

What the Design Does and Does Not Do

It multiplies the destruction points. Some gold is destroyed directly at the expensive vendor. Some resources are destroyed at 100% via turn-ins before they ever become gold. Some volume is destroyed at 15% when it crosses the neutral house and at 5% on ordinary faction sales. The algorithm can tighten or loosen these levers when measured generation and sink rates diverge.

It does not stop gold from being printed. Quests still pay, mobs still drop coin, and vendor trash still converts into raw gold. The gap between faucets and sinks can be narrowed and made responsive; it cannot be closed by design alone under a system that generates currency whenever players play. That is the practical limit. The proposals move the system from a set of fixed, mostly one-time sinks toward a set of recurring, adjustable ones that can react to the data the Auction Houses already produce.

The series stops here for now. Later posts can incorporate live median prices, listing volumes, and observed generation rates once more data exists, or examine specific edge cases (bot pressure, multi-boxing, or the interaction with the Black Market vendor caps). The core claim remains the one that opened the series: controlling gold inflation is a reasonable goal, and under the present generation rules it is still an uphill fight. These changes make the hill less steep.


Posts in this series:

  1. Money Circulation in WoW Forever — The Basic Flow
  2. Designing Better Sinks — Durability Destruction, Resource Turn-ins, and Dynamic Rebalancing
  3. Checking the Logic — AH Fees, Cycle Friction, and Numbered Recommendations
  4. Worked Examples — Rebinding Prices, Turn-in Stacks, and Algorithm Moves
  5. Series Summary — Why Gold Inflation Is Hard, and What Can Still Be Done

Share this post on:

Back to top