Post / EN /
Worked Examples — Rebinding Prices, Turn-in Stacks, and Algorithm Moves
Concrete calculations for the recommended starting numbers: vendor prices, resource turn-ins, deposit costs, and a sample weekly rebalance across the three markets.
These examples take the recommendations from the logic-check post and apply them to specific items using the documented Auction House rules (5% faction cut, 15% neutral cut, deposits at 5%/20%/60% of vendor sell value for 2/8/24 hours). All gold figures are in gold unless noted.
1. Rebinding Kit Vendor Price
Recommendation: Start the pure-gold vendor path at 50–100 g for a single-use kit.
Worked example:
Assume a craftable Rebinding Kit has settled at a faction AH median of 8 g.
- After the 5% cut a seller receives 7.60 g.
- 8× that median = 64 g.
- 12× that median = 96 g.
Recommended vendor price for this stage: 75 g.
At 75 g the vendor path costs roughly 9–10× the open-market price after cut. A player who refuses both crafting and turn-ins pays a clear premium. The algorithm can later move this number ±20% (so 60–90 g in the next reset) if measured gold surplus rises or falls.
Multi-charge variant: A 3-charge kit could vendor at 200 g (≈2.7× the single-use price). This keeps the per-use cost high while rewarding players who commit more gold at once.
2. Resource Turn-in Quantities
Recommendation: Set the material cost of one Rebinding at 1.2–1.5× the post-cut AH value of those materials.
Worked example A — Mid-tier cloth (Mageweave-style)
- AH median: 1.80 g per stack of 20.
- After 5% cut: 1.71 g.
- 1.3× post-cut value: 2.22 g equivalent.
Turn-in requirement: 26 Mageweave Cloth (or 1.3 stacks).
At the current median this costs the player the equivalent of 2.34 g in opportunity cost, slightly above the 1.71 g they would have received from selling. The turn-in is therefore competitive when the open-market kit is above ~2.5 g and unattractive when kits are cheaper.
Worked example B — Higher-tier ore (Thorium-style)
- AH median: 4.50 g per stack of 20.
- After 5% cut: 4.28 g.
- 1.4× post-cut value: 5.99 g equivalent.
Turn-in requirement: 27 Thorium Ore.
Opportunity cost ≈ 6.08 g. This sits cleanly inside the 1.2–1.5× band and removes a meaningful volume of ore that would otherwise become either vendor gold or AH listings.
Worked example C — Consumable reagent (Black Lotus proxy)
If a scarce reagent is already vendor-capped at 50 g (as with Mister Graphed), do not use it as the primary turn-in material. Instead require a larger quantity of a lower-tier material whose AH price is still elastic. Example: 40 stacks of a mid-tier herb whose post-cut value totals ~12 g for one Rebinding. This keeps the scarce reagent’s fixed vendor price as a separate ceiling rather than fighting it.
3. Algorithm Bounds and a Sample Weekly Move
Recommendation: ±25% maximum movement per reset; weekly cadence for large changes; 10–20% cross-market differentials.
Sample starting state (Week 0):
| Parameter | Alliance | Neutral (reference) | Horde |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rebinding vendor price | 75 g | 75 g | 75 g |
| Mageweave turn-in | 26 | — | 26 |
| Thorium turn-in | 27 | — | 27 |
Observed conditions during the week:
- Alliance AH median for Mageweave rose 18% (listings falling).
- Horde AH median for Thorium fell 12% (listings rising).
- Overall gold-generation surplus estimated at +6% above sinks.
Allowed Week 1 adjustments (inside ±25%):
- Mageweave turn-in (Alliance): 26 → 30 (+15%).
- Thorium turn-in (Horde): 27 → 24 (−11%).
- Rebinding vendor price (both factions): 75 g → 82 g (+9%).
- Neutral house left unchanged (it remains the transfer point only).
These moves stay well inside the ±25% cap. The 15% difference in Mageweave demand between Alliance and Horde is large enough to make some players move cloth through the Neutral house (paying the 15% cut) while still leaving the open market functional.
4. Deposit Cost on the Rebinding Kit
Recommendation: No special rule needed; the existing formula already scales.
Worked example (vendor sell value set to 10 g for deposit purposes):
| Duration | Deposit | % of 10 g |
|---|---|---|
| 2 hours | 0.50 g | 5% |
| 8 hours | 2.00 g | 20% |
| 24 hours | 6.00 g | 60% |
If the kit’s actual AH buyout is 8 g:
- A successful 8-hour sale returns the 2 g deposit and pays the seller 7.60 g after the 5% cut.
- An expired 24-hour listing costs the seller the full 6 g deposit.
The deposit is large enough relative to typical material profits that pure listing spam is expensive, yet small enough that a crafter who expects a sale within 8 hours is not heavily penalized. Neutral-house deposits (if applied at the higher rate reported in some client checks) would be larger still, further discouraging casual cross-faction listing of the kit itself.
5. Expected Destruction from Encouraged Cross-Market Flow
Recommendation: Treat the existing 15% Neutral cut as the cost of the A → N → H flow.
Worked example:
Suppose the algorithm induces 200 Rebinding Kits’ worth of Mageweave to move from Alliance to Horde in one week via the Neutral house.
- Each stack is sold once on Neutral.
- At an average Neutral sale price of 2.00 g per stack and a 15% cut, each stack destroys 0.30 g.
- 200 stacks destroy 60 g purely from the Neutral cut.
If those same 200 stacks had stayed on the Alliance faction house and sold there, only 5% (20 g) would have been destroyed. The extra 40 g destroyed is the incremental sink created by the cross-market incentive. Resource turn-ins remove additional material entirely (100% of the turned-in stacks never become gold). The two mechanisms stack: some volume is destroyed at 15% via Neutral, some volume is destroyed at 100% via turn-ins, and ordinary faction sales continue to destroy 5%.
Summary of the Worked Numbers
| Item / Parameter | Starting recommendation | Example result |
|---|---|---|
| Single-use Rebinding vendor | 50–100 g | 75 g when AH median is 8 g |
| Mageweave-style turn-in | 1.2–1.5× post-cut | 26 cloth (≈1.3×) |
| Thorium-style turn-in | 1.2–1.5× post-cut | 27 ore (≈1.4×) |
| Weekly movement cap | ±25% | +15% / −11% / +9% in sample |
| 10 g vendor-value kit deposit | Existing formula | 0.50 / 2.00 / 6.00 g |
| Incremental sink from 200 Neutral-moved stacks | 15% cut | +40 g vs. pure faction sales |
These figures can be adjusted once real median prices and listing volumes are available. The structure—vendor premium, turn-in opportunity cost slightly above post-cut sale value, hard movement caps, and reliance on the existing 5%/15% cuts—remains the same.
All calculations use the documented Forever Auction House rules: 5% faction cut, 15% neutral cut, and deposit percentages of vendor sell value. Vendor and median prices are illustrative pending live data.