Post / EN /
Checking the Logic — AH Fees, Cycle Friction, and Numbered Recommendations
The durability + resource + dynamic rebalancing proposals hold up against documented Auction House fees. Concrete numbers for cuts, deposits, and recommended target ranges.
The three-part design (durability destruction with multi-path Rebinding, permanent resource turn-ins, and a dynamic rebalancing algorithm that exploits the three markets) is structurally sound against the money-circulation map. It converts continuous resource and play generation into recurring sinks and transfers rather than relying solely on one-time training costs. The existing Auction House fee structure supplies useful friction numbers that can be used both to test the proposals and to set concrete parameters.
Documented AH Fees in Forever
These numbers come from client checks, forum confirmations, and consistent reporting across community sources (as of mid-November 2026):
| Rule | Faction AH | Neutral AH |
|---|---|---|
| Sale cut | 5% | 15% |
| Deposit (2 h) | 5% of vendor sell value | Higher (reported ~5× base in some checks) |
| Deposit (8 h) | 20% of vendor sell value | Higher |
| Deposit (24 h) | 60% of vendor sell value | Higher |
| Minimum deposit | 1 silver at launch → 1 copper after ~17–18 Nov maintenance | Same |
Deposit is refunded on sale and lost on expire or cancel. The cut is taken from the final sale price and is pure destruction.
Effective friction on a cross-market cycle
A full A → N → H move (sell on Neutral, then resell on the other faction) under equal prices destroys:
[ 1 - (0.95 \times 0.85) = 19.25% ]
of the listing value in cuts alone. Two faction sales destroy 9.75%. The Neutral house already functions as a high-friction transfer point. Any design that deliberately encourages goods to move A → N → H → N → A is therefore working with, not against, an existing ~15–19% destruction rate on the cross-faction legs.
Logic Check of the Three Proposals
Durability destruction + multi-path Rebinding
Creates recurring demand that scales with playtime and death rate rather than with character count. The three acquisition paths (craftable consumable → AH or self-use, player trade service, expensive vendor / rare-currency purchase) correctly split the outcome into pure sink, transfer, or mixed. This is stronger than ordinary repairs because the item can be destroyed, so the demand does not plateau after the first few repair cycles.
Permanent resource turn-ins
Remove materials before they become either vendor gold or AH listings. This is an upstream sink. It is complementary to the AH cut (which only destroys gold after a sale) and to the Rebinding vendor path (which destroys gold directly). The risk is that the turn-in reward becomes so attractive that the open market for those materials collapses; the dynamic algorithm is the intended counter to that risk.
Dynamic rebalancing + market variation
Makes the sinks responsive. Because the Neutral cut is already triple the faction cut, the algorithm can create or widen price/demand differentials that make the 15% leg worthwhile for arbitrage players without needing to invent new transfer taxes. Varying turn-in requirements or vendor buy prices by market is a low-risk way to generate those differentials.
The main design tension is player experience on the durability side (gear destruction feels punitive if the Rebinding path is too expensive or too rare) and stability of the algorithm (it needs hard bounds so it cannot swing parameters faster than players can adapt).
Numbered Recommendations
These use the documented fee structure as the baseline.
1. Rebinding Kit vendor price (pure gold sink path)
Target a price that is high enough to be a meaningful sink for players who refuse to engage the market or turn-ins, but not so high that it is only used by the top fraction of gold holders.
- Recommended range: 8–15× the typical AH median of the craftable Rebinding Kit once the market exists.
- Early-game proxy (before data): set the vendor price at roughly 50–100 g for a single-use kit that restores one item’s destruction counter. This sits above the 100 g Apprentice Riding cost and well above ordinary repairs, so it is not the default path.
- Scale later kits (or multi-charge versions) upward. The dynamic algorithm can move this number ±20% per reset based on measured gold-generation surplus.
2. Resource turn-in quantities
A turn-in that grants one Rebinding (or the materials/ability for one) should consume enough raw material that the opportunity cost is competitive with, but not strictly better than, selling the same stack on the AH after the 5% cut.
Example calculation for a mid-tier cloth or ore stack whose AH median is 2 g:
- After 5% cut the seller receives 1.90 g.
- A turn-in that requires that same stack (or its equivalent in lower mats) and grants one Rebinding is therefore attractive when the open-market kit price is above ~2 g, and unattractive when the kit is cheaper.
- Recommendation: start turn-in costs at 1.2–1.5× the post-cut AH value of the materials, then let the algorithm raise or lower the required quantity by up to 25% per reset according to whether that material’s listing volume is rising or falling.
3. Algorithm bounds and cadence
- Cadence: weekly, aligned with server reset. Daily is possible for deposit or vendor-price tweaks of ±5%, but larger changes (turn-in quantities, drop rates) should be weekly so players can observe and react.
- Hard bounds: no single parameter may move more than ±25% from its previous value in one reset, and no parameter may leave a predefined absolute band (for example, Rebinding vendor price stays between 30 g and 250 g in the first phase).
- Cross-market variation: the algorithm may set Alliance and Horde turn-in requirements or vendor buy prices independently, but the Neutral house remains the only cross-faction transfer point. A 10–20% difference in turn-in demand between factions is enough to generate arbitrage flow through the 15% Neutral cut without requiring the algorithm to invent new fees.
4. Deposit interaction for the new consumable
The Rebinding Kit will have a vendor sell value (even if high). Its listing deposit will therefore follow the normal formula. For a kit whose vendor value is set at 10 g:
- 2 h deposit: 0.50 g
- 8 h deposit: 2.00 g
- 24 h deposit: 6.00 g
These deposits are large enough that failed listings of high-priced kits are costly, which discourages pure spam while still allowing the craftable path to function as a transfer. No special deposit rule is required; the existing formula already scales correctly.
5. Expected destruction rate from encouraged cross-market flow
If the algorithm successfully induces 10% of Rebinding-related material volume to travel one Neutral leg, that volume loses 15% to the cut. Combined with ordinary faction sales (5%) and the resource turn-ins (100% of those materials removed), the design multiplies the number of destruction points without needing new percentage taxes. The 19.25% full-cycle figure is an upper bound that only appears when prices are identical; real arbitrage only occurs when the price gap exceeds the cut, so actual destruction will be lower but still positive.
Summary
The proposals are consistent with the existing fee structure. The 5%/15% cut differential already supplies a natural cost for the A → N → H flow the design wants to encourage. The main numbers to set first are the Rebinding vendor price (recommended starting band 50–100 g), the resource turn-in quantities (1.2–1.5× post-cut AH value), and the algorithm’s per-reset movement cap (±25%). With those bounds the system can respond to measured imbalances while remaining predictable enough for players who treat the Auction House as their primary activity.
Fee numbers drawn from client observations and community reporting on faction 5% / neutral 15% cuts and the 5%/20%/60% vendor-value deposit formula for 2/8/24-hour auctions. Minimum deposit change to 1 copper scheduled for mid-November 2026 maintenance.